UMOA: The two-speed normative integration of the new uniform banking law
On 16 June 2023, the Council of Ministers of the West African Monetary Union (UMOA) adopted a new uniform law on banking regulation, intended to harmonise the legal framework of the sector in the eight member states (Benin, Burkina Faso, Côte d'Ivoire, Guinea-Bissau, Mali, Niger, Senegal, Togo), under the supervision of the BCEAO. According to KONÉ Péléni Jonathan Aimé, doctor in private law, specialist in banking law, ATER at Université Toulouse Capitole and independent consultant, three years after its adoption, this text is "still not fully in force in all eight member states", hence the observation of a "two-speed" integration. This gap is not insignificant: a uniform banking law not transposed everywhere creates legal uncertainty for regional banking groups, complicates consolidated supervision and may weaken savers' and investors' confidence in the UMOA area. The substantive analysis – in particular the countries lagging behind, the precise administrative or political obstacles, and the possible role of contexts of political transition in certain Sahel states – is not detailed in the available elements. These questions remain open and would merit documentation in the continuation of the original article.
Ji-Elle
A uniform law with blurred contours
The new uniform law on banking regulation within the West African Monetary Union (UMOA) was adopted on 16 June 2023 with the aim of harmonising the legal framework of the banking sector in the eight member states. However, three years after its adoption by the Council of Ministers of the Union on 16 June 2023, this law is still not fully in force in all the countries concerned. This observation highlights a two-speed normative integration, where some states have managed to transpose the law, while others are still lagging behind, or have not even initiated the process. This situation raises important concerns. A uniform banking law that is not applied consistently across the member states generates legal uncertainty for regional banking groups. It also complicates consolidated supervision and may undermine the confidence of savers and investors in the UMOA area. Delays in transposing the law are often linked to administrative or political obstacles, particularly in countries undergoing periods of political transition.
Unequal progress in transposition
At present, only Benin and Senegal can claim full and effective transposition of the law. Benin has adopted legislation that faithfully takes up the innovations of the uniform law, while Senegal has also modernised its legal framework in line with community requirements. These two examples show that, despite transposition deadlines that exceed initial forecasts, states can move quickly when there is political will. Conversely, other countries such as Mali, Niger and Guinea-Bissau have not yet managed to transpose the law, and this situation is often exacerbated by unstable political contexts. Burkina Faso, although it recently adopted a draft law, remains uncertain as to the consolidation of this stage.
The consequences of normative fragmentation
The absence of uniform application of the banking law has significant practical consequences. Regional banking groups, whose main activity is organised precisely through a network of subsidiaries and branches covering several states of the Union, find themselves subject, for the same group, to distinct legal regimes depending on the jurisdiction considered: the 2007 law still in force in some states, the 2023 law fully applicable in others, texts in the process of adoption elsewhere. This legal uncertainty complicates the definition of harmonised governance and compliance policies at group level, and may, in the long term, generate distortions of competition between institutions according to their main state of establishment. It may lead to certain conflicts of law within the same sub-regional area. This factual observation also questions the coherence of the supervision exercised by the Banking Commission of UMOA, whose strengthened powers, although designed to improve the resilience of the banking system, depend largely on the transposition of the law in each member state. This legal dependence constitutes one of the major points of fragility in the regional supervision architecture.
The challenges of banking harmonisation
It highlights the structural limits of a harmonisation method which, since the beginnings of West African monetary integration, has relied on national transposition rather than direct application. Each member state is master of its own adoption timetable, which leads to differentiated transposition speeds. This situation highlights the tension between the ambition of a single banking law and the political and institutional reality of the Union. For African entrepreneurs and investors, this fragmentation can mean increased complexity in managing their activities at regional level. Regulatory differences can generate additional costs and legal risks, making strategic planning more difficult.
Source: Financial Afrik
---
Translated from the French original : [UMOA : L'intégration normative à deux vitesses de la nouvelle loi bancaire uniforme](/article/bea38b71-8877-4d6c-b5bc-77fb29dcb4d1)
Source : Financial Afrik
Lire l'article original ↗